Abstract: We study the gap-dependent bounds of two important algorithms for on-policy $Q$-learning for finite-horizon episodic tabular Markov Decision Processes (MDPs): UCB-Advantage (Zhang et al. 2020) and Q-EarlySettled-Advantage (Li et al. 2021). UCB-Advantage and Q-EarlySettled-Advantage improve upon the results based on Hoeffding-type bonuses and achieve the {almost optimal} $\sqrt{T}$-type regret bound in the worst-case scenario, where $T$ is the total number of steps. However, the benign structures of the MDPs such as a strictly positive suboptimality gap can significantly improve the regret. While gap-dependent regret bounds have been obtained for $Q$-learning with Hoeffding-type bonuses, it remains an open question to establish gap-dependent regret bounds for $Q$-learning using variance estimators in their bonuses and reference-advantage decomposition for variance reduction. We develop a novel error decompositionframework to prove gap-dependent regret bounds of UCB-Advantage and Q-EarlySettled-Advantage that are logarithmic in $T$ and improve upon existing ones for $Q$-learning algorithms. Moreover, we establish the gap-dependent bound for the policy switching cost of UCB-Advantage and improve that under the worst-case MDPs. To our knowledge, this paper presents the first gap-dependent regret analysis for $Q$-learning using variance estimators and reference-advantage decomposition and also provides the first gap-dependent analysis on policy switching cost for $Q$-learning.